goproblems.com

With successful launching of Josekipedia, would it be a good idea eliminating "joseki" as class in goproblems.com?
That would allow us saving a lot of space on the server and getting rid of about 20% of “junk” postings.
Authors could move their joseki problems to josekipedia voluntarily.

the 'joseki' category has definitely been rather problematic, and i guess you believe it doesn't deserve to exist. you may be right. what do others think? should joseki problems just be automatically generated from josekipedia?

i'm agree .

I'm sorry but I object to the suggestion.
There are many good joseki problems on the site, so we should not eliminate the joseki category. The site definitely needs joseki problems to be a comprehensive go problem resource.
Generating problems automatically from Josekipedia is a nice idea, but it cannot take the place of humanly created problems.

I see a case of misunderstanding. You probably meant fuseki (which joseki to play in the particular cituation?). In fact, I don't even know how one can make a problem out of joseki. With Josekipedia running, solving joseki problem is rediculously easy, - just open Josekipedia and see the answer.

I know the difference between joseki and fuseki.
We can create joseki problems by asking vital moves, asking how to refute trick play, and so on.

In this case you're right. But I yet to see such problem on the site. All joseki "problems" that I've seen here simply asking a dull question "what is the next move?"